On November 20, debates continued in the HACC in the case of former judge of the Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal, Ihor Petryk. The accused presented his position.
He is convinced that the verdict should be overturned. Petryk emphasized the bias of the first instance, the incompleteness of the review, and the inconsistency of the conclusions with the actual circumstances of the case.
According to him, the presiding judge systematically interrupted him during his free testimony, ignored written explanations, refused to interrogate key defense witnesses, and unjustifiably rejected a motion to conduct a computer-technical examination of the SRTP recordings.
Petryk insists that his meetings with the applicant Hennadiy Ostapenko were purely private and did not concern cases in the Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal. According to his version, Ostapenko approached him supposedly on behalf of Judge Smokovych for advice on the bankruptcy of a Kharkiv firm.
The accused assures that he did not present himself as a judge and did not promise decisions for money, and when the applicant began hinting at a bribe — he stopped answering calls altogether. Petryk explained the meeting near the Desnianskyi Court at the end of November 2016 as an attempt to retrieve an envelope with money that he had previously given to Ostapenko for his son in Kharkiv. The next morning, he personally visited the office of Deputy Head Mykhailo Smokovych, found out that he had not asked for anyone, and finally refused any assistance.
Petryk paid special attention to the alleged falsification of evidence and provocation of a crime by SBU officers, agent Ostapenko, and his assistant Dmytro Lavrentyev. Referring to expert research conclusions, he stated that the SRTP recordings were edited, and the paper protocols contained deliberate additions of phrases about a bribe that were not on the audio.
According to the ex-judge's version, his assistant acted in collusion with the investigation to justify himself: in a cafe, he carefully took a white envelope through a file so as not to leave fingerprints, and three hours later in the court corridor, he discreetly slipped it into Petryk's pocket under the pretext of returning money for his son.
Petryk considers the case fabricated since there are no surveillance camera recordings from the court that could capture the moment of money transfer and his fingerprints on the envelope. Ihor Petryk will continue his speech in the debates on November 23.
This material was translated using artificial intelligence. Inaccuracies are possible.