On October 29, the Grand Chamber of the Supreme Court overturned the decision of the High Council of Justice dated May 5, 2026, which issued a warning to the judges of the Appeals Chamber of the HACC Inna Kalugina, Oleksandr Semennikov, and Dmytro Mykhailenko. The reason was that the HCJ did not substantiate its conclusions.
The disciplinary case concerns events of January 2021. At that time, the judges partially satisfied the appeal of the SAP prosecutor against the ruling of the Pechersk Court, which annulled the suspicion against former Deputy Minister of Justice Olena Lukash in the NABU case. They closed the proceedings on the defenders' complaint because at that time the suspicion in this case could not be appealed to an investigating judge. The HCJ believed that the appeal should have been considered by the Kyiv Court of Appeal, and the repeated review violated the principle of finality of court decisions. The Council considered the violation obvious and intentional.
The Grand Chamber did not decide which court should have considered the appeal. It only pointed out that the HCJ did not explain why the violation was obvious and identified three gaps in its reasoning:
- The Third Disciplinary Chamber of the HCJ emphasized that judicial practice regarding jurisdiction is ambiguous. Simply proposing another interpretation is not enough — it is necessary to take into account established practice of the Supreme Court.
- The HCJ did not explain why the conclusion of the HACC Appeals Chamber courts was «opposite» to the ruling of the Cassation Criminal Court and why the jurisdiction of proceedings, complaints, and appeals are the same.
- The HCJ did not refute that the Kyiv Court of Appeal and the HACC Appeals Chamber considered complaints from different parties within different limits. Therefore, it is unclear why it is a repeated review.
The ruling is final and not subject to appeal. This does not conclude the disciplinary case, as the HCJ will reconsider it.
Back in June, TI Ukraine analyzed this HCJ decision and pointed out the same gaps in reasoning, as well as Supreme Court practice that previously confirmed the position of the HACC Appeals Chamber judges.
This material was translated using artificial intelligence. Inaccuracies are possible.