On November 12, the court concluded the debates in the case of People's Deputy Lyudmila Marchenko and returned to the stage of questioning her assistant Anastasia Kolesnik. During the trial in the first instance, she stated that her intention to receive money arose spontaneously. She was also pressured by one of the men for whom she arranged documents. At that time, Marchenko's defense insisted that the People's Deputy was not aware that her assistant was taking money. In fact, she placed all the blame on Kolesnik.
In the Appeals Chamber, the assistant changed her testimony and revealed details about the men's transfer abroad.
Defense position in the debates
The People's Deputy's defender noted that he sees a number of procedural violations committed during the pre-trial investigation stage. He also mentioned that the accusation is based solely on assumptions. He is convinced that there is no clear formulation in the indictment that Marchenko took bribes for arranging departures abroad. There is also no information about who exactly and to whom the money was given.
Furthermore, the defender disagrees with the crime imputed to Marchenko by the investigation. The lawyer believes she did not receive any benefit and exerted no influence.
He also emphasized the interrogation of individuals who approached Kolesnik and Marchenko for arranging departures abroad Bondzyukh and Hrytsyo. He is convinced that they could not clearly explain who demanded bribes from them and did not confirm the People's Deputy's involvement in the crime.
He requested to dismiss the prosecutor's appeal and to satisfy the defense's appeal.
Prosecutor's position in the debates
The prosecutor is convinced that there could not have been a situation where Kolesnik took money independently without informing Marchenko. He is convinced that the video showing Marchenko throwing money over a fence clearly demonstrates her guilt.
In his opinion, Marchenko used her parliamentary influence to receive bribes. He is convinced that the first instance analyzed all evidence and correctly assigned punishment.
The prosecutor also noted that there were no violations during the pre-trial investigation stage and provided supporting documents showing that the defense is mistaken.
The prosecutor is convinced Kolesnik's function was simply to take money. He noted that the indictment states: Marchenko gave clear instructions on how to act.
He also mentioned that in the correspondence between the accused, it is clear they established a scheme for receiving bribes. The defenders' thesis that they were discussing ordinary everyday topics does not correspond to reality.
The prosecutor requested to dismiss the defense's appeals and increase Marchenko's punishment to 5 years of imprisonment.
Re-examination of Kolesnik
Re-examination of Kolesnik
The court also returned to the stage of evidence examination exclusively concerning the questioning of assistant Anastasia Kolesnik due to discrepancies in her testimony between the first and appellate courts. Meanwhile, Marchenko's defense objected to returning to this stage, as it would go beyond the scope of the appeal.
Kolesnik stated that she has been working with Marchenko for a long time introduced by her father. She mentioned attending a meeting with Andriy Bondzyukh, where he asked her to arrange a departure abroad for personal purposes and for an acquaintance, Hrytsyo.
With this request, she approached Marchenko, to which the People's Deputy confirmed that arranging documents "might not be free." Kolesnik communicated the agreed price to clients, after which she began processing all documents. Later, she met with a man and received money. When asked by the prosecutor, Kolesnik noted that Marchenko quoted the amounts. The assistant kept $200 from each client for herself. She handed over $6,000 and $5,800 to Marchenko.
Kolesnik claims that Marchenko's role was to influence funds for these individuals' departures under the guise of volunteering.
Kolesnik also explained why she changed her position: lawyers in the case advised sharing guilt equally with Marchenko.
This material was translated using artificial intelligence. Inaccuracies are possible.