The HACC acquitted Oleksii Basan, former director of SE Agency of Local Roads of Poltava Region, of abuse of official position and misuse of budget funds in road repairs in Poltava Region. However, the HACC Appeals Chamber revised the verdict.
In 2018, the list of local roads was amended to allocate almost UAH 30 million for design and survey works. Three roads were divided into 22 sections, each 4–6 km long. Basan organized the procurement of design services through Prozorro. The tenders were won by construction company Avtostroi LLC, Derzhdorproekt LLC, USP Ukrbudproekt, and USP Inspetsproekt LLC.
According to the investigation, Basan unlawfully organized the procurement without proper funding in place, having single-handedly divided the subject of procurement into 22 sections. This made it possible to procure the services from predetermined companies without open tendering, under the below-threshold procurement procedure. Since roads are linear facilities, the design should have been carried out for the three roads as a whole rather than for separate sections. Basan pleaded not guilty, claiming that he had acted within his powers and in the interests of the enterprise and that some of the evidence was inadmissible.
The HACC found Basan not guilty due to the absence of elements of a criminal offense, ruling a number of pieces of the prosecution’s evidence inadmissible.
However, the HACC Appeals Chamber established that the first-instance court had wrongly acquitted Basan under the article on misuse of funds: in 2018, the law clearly distinguished between funding areas, and the subvention for local roads could be used only for construction or repairs, not for design works. The Appeals Chamber found that Basan, who has a law degree and experience working at the SSU, had acted intentionally by initiating the unlawful transfer of almost UAH 29 million. As for abuse of power, the Appeals Chamber found the artificial division of the roads unlawful but acquitted the official, as the prosecutors failed to properly prove the exact amount of losses, which is a mandatory element of this offense.
The HACC Appeals Chamber found Basan guilty under Article 210(2) of the Criminal Code and sentenced him to 2 years of service restriction with 20% of his monetary allowance withheld for the state, as well as a 2-year ban on holding managerial positions at state-owned or municipally owned enterprises. He was acquitted under Article 364(2) of the Criminal Code because the amount of damage had not been proven. The court ordered that the bail of UAH 3.72 million be returned to the bail payers.