Search

Procurement with losses of UAH 780,000: the case of ex-managers of Zaporizhzhia Electric Locomotive Repair Plant

  • Date of commencement of the case: 26/09/2019
Track case progress If you would like to follow the case, leave your email and get updates sent straight to your inbox
Procurement with losses of UAH 780,000: the case of ex-managers of Zaporizhzhia Electric Locomotive Repair Plant Procurement with losses of UAH 780,000: the case of ex-managers of Zaporizhzhia Electric Locomotive Repair Plant

Case description

On April 29, 2024, the HACC found Hennadii Politykin, former director of the Zaporizhzhia Electric Locomotive Repair Plant (ZELRP); his deputy Oleksandr Fenin, and Leonid Yermakov, head of a private firm; guilty of organizing the purchase of gear wheels at inflated prices.

According to the investigation, Yermakov, a representative of SK Smart LLC, conspired with ZELRP management to ensure that his company got awarded in the open tender for the purchase of 30 large gear wheels for ChS-4 electric trains. ZELRP Director Politykin was supposed to remove other bidders, and his deputy Fenin would have formalized the victory of the private firm.

In December 2014, after disclosing the bids, SK Smart LLC turned out to have the highest price at the tender, but the defendants entered false information into the bid evaluation protocol, thus allowing the company to get awarded. They had agreed with representatives of other companies before that to artificially inflate their price offers. Subsequently, a contract was signed for almost UAH 2.5 million. The state suffered UAH 789,000 in losses. 

The defendants’ actions were qualified under Article 364(2) of the Criminal Code of Ukraine. Yermakov was sentenced to 5 years in prison and a fine of UAH 17,000; Politykin and Fenin were sentenced to 4 years in prison with a similar fine. Additionally, the convicted persons were banned from holding certain positions for 3 years.

 

  • Proceeding No.: 22015080000000010
  • Case No.: 331/4672/16-к
  • Incriminated: Article 364, part 2
Instance Key parties Instance /Key parties:
HACC AC
28/06/2024

Panel of judges: Chorna V.V.

HACC
21/09/2020

Panel of judges: Maslov V.V., Zadorozhna L.I., Fedorak L.M., Fedorak L.M., Shkodin Ya.V., Fedorov O.V.

Lawyer: Senyk S.H., Levkovets A.Yu., Vynohradov M.H.

Prosecutor: Olefir Yu.O.

CCC
31/07/2020

Panel of judges: Ivanenko I.V., Kovtunovych M.I., Fomin S.B., Buleiko O.L.

HACC AC
30/04/2020

Panel of judges: Panaid I.V., Bodnar S.B., Pankulych V.I.

Lawyer: Levkovets A.Yu., Senyk S.H.

Prosecutor: Olefir Yu.O.

HACC
26/09/2019

Panel of judges: Maslov V.V., Fedorak L.M.

Lawyer: Levkovets A.Yu., Vynohradov M.H., Senyk S.H.

Prosecutor: Olefir Yu.O.

Infographics

THE CASE OF EX-MANAGERS OF ZAPORIZHZHIA ELECTRIC LOCOMOTIVE REPAIR PLANT

The former management of Zaporizhzhia Electric Locomotive Repair Plant caused losses to the enterprise of more than UAH 780,000 by purchasing gear wheels at inflated prices.

  • December 30, 2014
    The ZELRP transferred UAH 1.8 million to a private company following the artificially arranged awarding in open bidding
  • September 19, 2019
    The case was transferred to the HACC
  • January 17, 2020
    The HACC exempted Politykin and Fenin from liability for forgery in office as the statute of limitations had expired
  • pic
    April 29, 2024
    The HACC delivered guilty verdicts against Yermakov, Politykin, and Fenin—imprisonment, fines, and a ban on holding certain positions
  • June 28, 2024
    The HACC Appeals Chamber initiated appellate proceedings following the defense counsel's appeals

Decisions from the Register

Case No. Court Decision date Decision type
331/4672/16-к HACC 26/09/2019 On the appointment of a preparatory court hearing
331/4672/16-к HACC 08/10/2019
331/4672/16-к HACC 08/10/2019
331/4672/16-к CCC 15/10/2019
331/4672/16-к CCC 22/10/2019
331/4672/16-к HACC AC 04/11/2019 On the appointment of a new trial in the court of the first instance
331/4672/16-к HACC 05/11/2019
331/4672/16-к HACC 05/11/2019
331/4672/16-к CCC 05/11/2019
331/4672/16-к HACC AC 13/11/2019
331/4672/16-к HACC AC 13/11/2019
331/4672/16-к HACC 17/01/2020
331/4672/16-к HACC 17/01/2020
331/4672/16-к HACC 20/01/2020
331/4672/16-к HACC 10/03/2020
331/4672/16-к HACC 10/03/2020
331/4672/16-к HACC AC 30/04/2020 Opening of appeal proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC AC 30/04/2020
331/4672/16-к HACC 21/05/2020
331/4672/16-к HACC 21/05/2020
331/4672/16-к HACC AC 03/06/2020
331/4672/16-к HACC AC 16/06/2020
331/4672/16-к HACC AC 16/06/2020
331/4672/16-к HACC 08/07/2020
331/4672/16-к HACC 09/07/2020
331/4672/16-к HACC 09/07/2020
331/4672/16-к HACC 14/07/2020
331/4672/16-к HACC 15/07/2020
331/4672/16-к HACC 15/07/2020
331/4672/16-к HACC 15/07/2020
331/4672/16-к HACC 15/07/2020
331/4672/16-к CCC 31/07/2020 On the refusal to open cassation proceedings
331/4672/16-к CCC 27/08/2020 On the refusal to open cassation proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 21/09/2020 On the appointment of a trial
331/4672/16-к HACC 21/09/2020 On the appointment of a trial
331/4672/16-к HACC 23/09/2020
331/4672/16-к HACC 09/12/2020
331/4672/16-к HACC 11/12/2020
331/4672/16-к HACC 21/12/2020
331/4672/16-к HACC 06/01/2021
331/4672/16-к HACC 20/01/2021
331/4672/16-к HACC 02/03/2021
331/4672/16-к HACC 07/04/2021
331/4672/16-к HACC 20/04/2021
331/4672/16-к HACC 23/04/2021
331/4672/16-к HACC 23/04/2021
331/4672/16-к HACC 17/05/2021
331/4672/16-к HACC 17/05/2021
331/4672/16-к HACC 24/05/2021
331/4672/16-к HACC 07/06/2021
331/4672/16-к HACC 11/06/2021
331/4672/16-к HACC 11/06/2021
331/4672/16-к HACC 05/07/2021
331/4672/16-к HACC 13/09/2021
331/4672/16-к HACC 27/09/2021
331/4672/16-к HACC 21/10/2021
331/4672/16-к HACC 04/11/2021
331/4672/16-к HACC 17/11/2021
331/4672/16-к HACC 03/12/2021
331/4672/16-к HACC 11/01/2022
331/4672/16-к HACC 18/01/2022
331/4672/16-к HACC 16/02/2022
331/4672/16-к HACC 16/02/2022
331/4672/16-к HACC 16/02/2022
331/4672/16-к HACC 16/02/2022 Separate opinion of the HACC judge
331/4672/16-к HACC 23/05/2022 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 25/05/2022 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 08/06/2022 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 05/07/2022 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 07/07/2022 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 11/07/2022
331/4672/16-к HACC 21/07/2022 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 28/07/2022 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 06/09/2022 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 29/09/2022 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 19/10/2022 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 03/11/2022 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 13/12/2022 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 09/01/2023 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 02/02/2023 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 14/03/2023 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 17/03/2023 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 24/03/2023
331/4672/16-к HACC 24/03/2023
331/4672/16-к HACC 04/04/2023 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 14/04/2023
331/4672/16-к HACC 14/04/2023
331/4672/16-к HACC 17/05/2023 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 22/05/2023 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 05/06/2023 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 07/06/2023 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 04/07/2023 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 04/09/2023 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 05/09/2023 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 27/09/2023 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 05/10/2023 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 22/11/2023 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 08/12/2023
331/4672/16-к HACC 08/12/2023
331/4672/16-к HACC 11/01/2024 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 05/04/2024 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 12/04/2024 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC 29/04/2024 Verdicts
331/4672/16-к HACC AC 12/06/2024 On leaving the appeal without action
331/4672/16-к HACC AC 12/06/2024 On leaving the appeal without action
331/4672/16-к HACC AC 12/06/2024 On leaving the appeal without action
331/4672/16-к HACC AC 28/06/2024 Opening of appeal proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC AC 28/06/2024 Opening of appeal proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC AC 30/07/2024 Completion of the preparation and appointment of the appeal hearing
331/4672/16-к HACC AC 20/09/2024 On leaving the appeal without action
331/4672/16-к HACC AC 16/10/2024
331/4672/16-к HACC AC 16/10/2024
331/4672/16-к HACC AC 18/10/2024 On leaving the appeal without action
331/4672/16-к HACC AC 29/10/2024 Opening of appeal proceedings
331/4672/16-к HACC AC 31/10/2024
331/4672/16-к HACC AC 04/11/2024
331/4672/16-к HACC AC 04/11/2024