Search

Case of former MoD official on embezzlement of UAH 1.5 billion during procurement of ammunition

  • The date of the first court decision within a pre-trial investigation: 02/02/2024
Track case progress If you would like to follow the case, leave your email and get updates sent straight to your inbox
Case of former MoD official on embezzlement of UAH 1.5 billion during procurement of ammunition Case of former MoD official on embezzlement of UAH 1.5 billion during procurement of ammunition

Case description

The NABU-SAPO suspects former Defense Ministry official Oleksandr Liev of allegedly embezzling almost UAH 1.5 billion during the purchase of ammunition together with his accomplices. 

According to the prosecution, Oleksandr Khoroshayev, representative of the private company Sevotech spol. S.r.o., organized a group that involved Oleksandr Liev, former acting director of the Department of Military Technical Policy, Development of Armaments and Military Equipment of the Ministry of Defense.

The company signed a contract with Lviv Arsenal LLC for the supply of mortar rounds in August 2022. Subsequently, in October 2022, MoD officials signed a contract for the purchase of 40,000 120 mm mortar rounds and 60,000 82 mm mortar rounds worth almost UAH 1.5 billion.

Liev's role was to enter into an additional agreement to the contract that changed the terms of payment for the ammunition. In breach of the contract, Liev also prepared and approved a draft decision to make an advance payment of 97% of the contract price, which at the time amounted to more than UAH 1.3 billion. After receiving the funds, Lviv Arsenal transferred the money to the accounts of Khoroshayev's company without supporting documents, from where the funds were transferred to another company.

Shortly before that, the Ministry of Defense had added Lviv Arsenal LLC to the list of special arms importers. When the time came in December 2022 for the first supply of rounds, it became known that Lviv Arsenal was supposed to be assisted by Khoroshayev's company, but it did not have the ammunition. The rounds were in another country with which no one had signed an export license. 

This case attracts attention because it was initially investigated by the National Police, but later the NABU took it on, as the Ministry of Defense was among the allegedly involved participants. However, in March 2024, the SAPO returned the case to the police because the involvement of the Ministry of Defense was not established. 

In addition to Oleksandr Liev, the case involves Oleksandr Khoroshayev, representative of a private company;, Yuriiy Zbitnev, director of Lviv Arsenal LLC and Toomas Nahkur, head of the Defense Ministry's department. Their actions were classified under Article 191, clause 5 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine.

  • Proceeding No.: 42023000000000674
  • Case No.: 991/772/24, 991/726/24, 991/767/24, 991/770/24, 991/769/24, 991/768/24, 991/732/24, 991/986/24, 991/1012/24, 991/953/24, 991/1011/24, 991/731/24, 991/990/24, 991/988/24, 991/1033/24, 991/1125/24, 991/1105/24, 991/1295/24, 991/733/24, 991/1586/24, 991/1523/24, 991/1743/24, 991/1744/24, 991/1802/24, 991/1503/24, 991/2051/24, 991/2057/24, 991/1952/24, , 991/2569/24, 991/3423/24, 757/19904/24-к, 991/5737/24, 991/6282/24, 991/9343/24, 991/11975/24, 991/11685/24, 991/12729/24, 991/12731/24, 991/12705/24, 991/12702/24, 991/12707/24, 991/12735/24, 991/12706/24, 991/12708/24, 991/12709/24, 991/12728/24, 991/12726/24, 991/12701/24, 991/12857/24, 991/12893/24, 991/12892/24, 991/12896/24, 991/12895/24, 991/13015/24, 991/12899/24, 991/12890/24, 991/12898/24, 991/12897/24
  • Incriminated: Article 191, part 5, Article 369-2, part 1, Article 209, part 3
Instance Key parties Instance /Key parties:
CCC
22/04/2024

Panel of judges: Loboiko L.M.

HACC
31/01/2024

Panel of judges: Shkodin Ya.V., Sikora K.O., Voronko V.D., Tkachenko O.V., Fedorak L.M.

Infographics

CASE OF OLEKSANDR LIEV

Oleksandr Liev and other accomplices allegedly embezzled more than UAH 1.3 billion during the purchase of ammunition for the AFU.

  • October-November 2022
    Ministry of Defense officials signed a contract for the purchase of artillery shells, and after transferring the funds, obtained almost UAH 1.5 billion
  • May 29, 2023
    The Pechersk District Court of Kyiv seized part of the funds held on the accounts of Lviv Arsenal LLC
  • pic
    January 27, 2024
    The defendants in the case were served with suspicion notices
  • January 29, 2024
    The HACC did not choose an interim measure for Liev
  • February 2, 2024
    The HACC released Nakhkur on his own recognizance
  • February 5, 2024
    Liev's case was transferred to the NABU
  • February 5, 2024
    The HACC placed Zbitnev under nightly house arrest
  • pic
    February 12, 2024
    The HACC AC took Liev into custody with an alternative of UAH 50 million bail
  • March 13, 2024
    Liev's case was transferred to the National Police
  • March 15, 2024
    The HACC released Liev on his own recognizance
  • April 9, 2024
    The HACC AC overturned the investigating judge's decision to change the interim measure and referred the case for a new trial to the court of the first instance
  • April 17, 2024
    The HACC left the motion to change the interim measure without consideration, as the deadline for this had already expired

Decisions from the Register

Case No. Court Decision date Decision type
991/772/24 HACC 31/01/2024
991/726/24 HACC AC 02/02/2024 On the appointment of a new trial in the court of the first instance
991/767/24 HACC 06/02/2024
991/770/24 HACC 06/02/2024
991/769/24 HACC 06/02/2024
991/768/24 HACC 06/02/2024
991/768/24 HACC 06/02/2024
991/769/24 HACC 06/02/2024
991/767/24 HACC 06/02/2024
991/770/24 HACC 06/02/2024
991/732/24 HACC 08/02/2024
991/732/24 HACC 08/02/2024
991/986/24 HACC 08/02/2024
991/1012/24 HACC 08/02/2024
991/953/24 HACC 08/02/2024
991/1011/24 HACC 08/02/2024
991/953/24 HACC 08/02/2024
991/1011/24 HACC 08/02/2024
991/1012/24 HACC 08/02/2024
991/986/24 HACC 08/02/2024
991/726/24 HACC 12/02/2024
991/726/24 HACC 12/02/2024
991/726/24 HACC AC 12/02/2024 Decision on partial granting of appeals
991/726/24 HACC AC 12/02/2024 Decision on partial granting of appeals
991/731/24 HACC 13/02/2024
991/731/24 HACC 13/02/2024
991/990/24 HACC 13/02/2024
991/990/24 HACC 13/02/2024
991/988/24 HACC 14/02/2024
991/1033/24 HACC 14/02/2024
991/1125/24 HACC 14/02/2024
991/1105/24 HACC 14/02/2024
991/1125/24 HACC 14/02/2024
991/988/24 HACC 14/02/2024
991/1295/24 HACC 22/02/2024
991/1295/24 HACC 22/02/2024
991/733/24 HACC AC 04/03/2024 On the appointment of a new trial in the court of the first instance
991/1295/24 HACC AC 04/03/2024 On the appointment of a new trial in the court of the first instance
991/1586/24 HACC 04/03/2024
991/1523/24 HACC 05/03/2024
991/1523/24 HACC 05/03/2024
991/1743/24 HACC 07/03/2024
991/1744/24 HACC 07/03/2024
991/1744/24 HACC 07/03/2024
991/1743/24 HACC 07/03/2024
991/1802/24 HACC 08/03/2024
991/1802/24 HACC 08/03/2024
991/1503/24 HACC 11/03/2024
991/1503/24 HACC 11/03/2024
991/733/24 HACC 12/03/2024
991/733/24 HACC 12/03/2024
991/1586/24 HACC 12/03/2024
991/733/24 HACC AC 12/03/2024
991/733/24 HACC AC 12/03/2024
991/2051/24 HACC 13/03/2024
991/1295/24 HACC 14/03/2024
991/1295/24 HACC AC 14/03/2024 Decision on partial granting of appeals
991/1295/24 HACC AC 14/03/2024 Decision on partial granting of appeals
991/1295/24 HACC 14/03/2024
991/2051/24 HACC AC 19/03/2024 On the appointment of a new trial in the court of the first instance
991/2057/24 HACC 01/04/2024
991/2057/24 HACC 01/04/2024
991/1952/24 HACC 02/04/2024
991/1952/24 HACC 02/04/2024
991/2057/24 HACC 05/04/2024
991/2057/24 HACC 05/04/2024
991/2051/24 HACC AC 09/04/2024 Decision on partial granting of appeals
991/2051/24 HACC AC 09/04/2024
CCC 09/04/2024
991/2051/24 HACC AC 09/04/2024
991/2051/24 HACC AC 09/04/2024 Decision on partial granting of appeals
991/2051/24 HACC 17/04/2024
991/2051/24 CCC 22/04/2024 On the refusal to open cassation proceedings
991/2569/24 HACC AC 14/05/2024
991/1952/24 HACC AC 14/05/2024
991/1952/24 HACC AC 14/05/2024
991/2569/24 HACC AC 14/05/2024
991/3423/24 HACC 27/05/2024
991/1952/24 HACC 04/06/2024
991/3423/24 HACC 04/06/2024
991/2569/24 HACC 05/06/2024
991/2569/24 HACC 05/06/2024
991/2051/24 CCC 13/06/2024 On leaving the cassation appeal without motion
757/19904/24-к HACC AC 01/07/2024 On the return of the appeal
991/5737/24 HACC 08/07/2024
991/2051/24 CCC 11/07/2024 On the opening of cassation proceedings
991/2051/24 CCC 11/07/2024
991/6282/24 HACC 22/07/2024
991/6282/24 HACC 26/07/2024
991/6282/24 HACC AC 04/09/2024
991/6282/24 HACC AC 04/09/2024
991/9343/24 HACC 19/09/2024 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
991/9343/24 HACC 23/09/2024
991/9343/24 HACC 23/09/2024
991/11975/24 HACC 22/10/2024
991/11975/24 HACC 22/10/2024
991/11685/24 HACC AC 28/10/2024 On the appointment of a new trial in the court of the first instance
991/11685/24 HACC AC 04/11/2024 Decision on partial granting of appeals
991/11685/24 HACC AC 04/11/2024 Decision on partial granting of appeals
991/12729/24 HACC 13/11/2024
991/12731/24 HACC 13/11/2024
991/12705/24 HACC 13/11/2024
991/12702/24 HACC 13/11/2024
991/12707/24 HACC 13/11/2024
991/12735/24 HACC 13/11/2024
991/12706/24 HACC 13/11/2024
991/12708/24 HACC 13/11/2024
991/12709/24 HACC 13/11/2024
991/12728/24 HACC 13/11/2024
991/12726/24 HACC 13/11/2024
991/12701/24 HACC AC 20/11/2024
991/12701/24 HACC 20/11/2024
991/12857/24 HACC 26/11/2024
991/12857/24 HACC 26/11/2024
991/12893/24 HACC 27/11/2024 Decision on temporary access
991/12892/24 HACC 27/11/2024 Decision on temporary access
991/12896/24 HACC 27/11/2024
991/12895/24 HACC 27/11/2024
991/13015/24 HACC 04/12/2024
991/13015/24 HACC 04/12/2024
991/12899/24 HACC 06/12/2024
991/12890/24 HACC 06/12/2024
991/12898/24 HACC 06/12/2024
991/12897/24 HACC 06/12/2024