The case of misappropriation of UAH 13 billion from Ukrnafta: the first episode

The case of misappropriation of UAH 13 billion from Ukrnafta: the first episode
Start of the trial 24 September 2019
Instance HACC
Stage of criminal proceedings Pre-trial investigation

The NABU and SAPO suspect former Ukrnafta management and directors of several companies of embezzling over UAH 13 billion from the oil and gas producer. The case consists of two episodes that occurred in 2015.

According to the pre-trial investigation, in March–August 2015, auctions were held for the sale of Ukrnafta's petroleum products. The winning bidders — Prykarpattia-Naftotrade LLC, Techtrade Group LLC, Kotlas LLC, Halnafta LLC, and Harant-UTN LLC — were entitled to purchase oil from Ukrnafta. The total value of the signed contracts was UAH 10.7 billion.

Under applicable legal requirements, Ukrnafta was not permitted to deliver products without full advance payment. However, according to the NABU, the petroleum products were nevertheless delivered on an advance basis, processed at the Kremenchuk Oil Refinery, and subsequently sold.

The events of the second episode of the case are covered in a separate material. Regarding the second episode, the investigation holds that in July 2015, Ukrnafta entered into 70 petroleum product purchase agreements with Kotlas LLC for a total value of nearly UAH 3 billion. The funds were paid out, yet Ukrnafta never received the petroleum products. Investigators assert that the money was routed offshore through the aforementioned Kotlas LLC, then through VTF Avias LLC, with the ultimate beneficiaries being legal entities within the orbit of the Privat Group.

The case has since been referred to court.

Oleksii Kushch, former Chairman of Ukrnafta's Management Board
Oleksii Kushch, former Chairman of Ukrnafta's Management Board

The case involves:

  • former Ukrnafta Chairman Oleksii Kushch,
  • former Deputy Head of one of Ukrnafta's departments Nataliia Kernytska,
  • former Head of one of Ukrnafta's divisions Liudmyla Kyianytsia,
  • former Director of Prykarpattia-Naftotrade LLC Bohdan Zhuk,
  • former Director of Techtrade Group LLC Oleksandra Volovodenko,
  • former Director of Kotlas LLC Oleksandr Shal,
  • former Director of Halnafta LLC Petro Zvieriev.

All defendants are charged under Article 191(5) of the Criminal Code of Ukraine. In December 2022, four suspects were declared wanted: Volovodenko, Zhuk, Shal, and Zvieriev. With respect to these individuals, the HACC ruled to conduct special in-absentia pre-trial proceedings.

 

Proceeding No. 42015000000000722
Subjects
  • Business
  • Head of a state or municipal enterprise/institution
Qualification
Article 191, part 5, Article 364, part 2, Article 368, part 4, Article 369-2, part 1, Article 209, part 3, Article 366, part 1
Pre-trial cases №
  • 991/436/26
  • 991/6642/23
  • 991/6643/23
  • 991/5846/23
  • 991/4281/23
  • 991/4034/23
  • 991/2439/23
  • 991/2337/23
  • 991/2401/23
  • 991/2489/23
  • 991/2228/23
  • 991/178/23
  • 991/2488/23
  • 991/2181/23
  • 991/249/23
  • 991/412/23
  • 991/1509/23
  • 991/410/23
  • 991/250/23
  • 991/248/23
  • 991/247/23
  • 991/411/23
  • 991/316/23
  • 991/6535/22
  • 991/5844/22
  • 991/5843/22
  • 991/5698/22
  • 991/5345/22
  • 991/3597/22
  • 991/5013/22
  • 991/5015/22
  • 991/5014/22
  • 991/5089/22
  • 991/4883/22
  • 991/4884/22
  • 991/4463/22
  • 991/4460/22
  • 991/3937/22
  • 991/3593/22
  • 991/3596/22
  • 991/3445/22
  • 991/3447/22
  • 991/3446/22
  • 991/3595/22
  • 991/4131/22
  • 991/3811/22
  • 991/3600/22
  • 991/3812/22
  • 991/3744/22
  • 991/3746/22
  • 991/3745/22
  • 991/3742/22
  • 991/3743/22
  • 991/3387/22
  • 991/3386/22
  • 991/3367/22
  • 991/3365/22
  • 991/3366/22
  • 991/3363/22
  • 991/7072/21
  • 991/6104/21
  • 991/5235/21
  • 991/5237/21
  • 991/5236/21
  • 991/4831/21
  • 991/4834/21
  • 991/4799/21
  • 991/4800/21
  • 991/4798/21
  • 991/4797/21
  • 991/4312/21
  • 991/3327/21
  • 991/3326/21
  • 991/3328/21
  • 991/3215/21
  • 991/3217/21
  • 991/3218/21
  • 991/3216/21
  • 991/2450/21
  • 991/2006/21
  • 991/2007/21
  • 991/2005/21
  • 991/2009/21
  • 991/611/21
  • 991/1475/21
  • 991/1274/21
  • 991/1335/21
  • 991/1334/21
  • 991/780/21
  • 991/654/21
  • 991/655/21
  • 991/484/21
  • 991/656/21
  • 991/396/21
  • 991/400/21
  • 991/10049/20
  • 991/9974/20
  • 760/24541/19
  • 991/7604/20
  • 991/5784/20
  • 991/6286/20
  • 991/6285/20
  • 991/3568/20
  • 991/786/20
  • 757/47095/19-к
  • 991/2171/20
  • 991/1234/20
  • 4910/60/19
  • 760/7677/19
  • 760/32037/18
Instance
The case is at the stage of pre-trial investigation
Misappropriation of UAH 13 billion from Ukrnafta
Pre-trial investigation

У 2015 року тодішнє керівництво «Укрнафти» разом з керівниками низки ТОВ імовірно розтратили 13 млрд грн компанії через недотримання умов укладених контрактів на постачання нафтопродукції.

Article 191(5) of the Criminal Code of Ukraine

  • pic
    March-August 2015
    Ukrnafta held auctions and supplied a number of companies with petroleum products worth UAH 10 billion without receiving payment for them in full
  • pic
    July 2015
    Ukrnafta paid UAH 3 billion for gasoline that was never delivered, but ended up in offshore accounts
  • pic
    September 2, 2022
    the NABU and the SAPO served a number of people with suspicion notices of embezzlement of over UAH 13.8 billion from Ukrnafta
  • September 17, 2022
    Law enforcement officers conducted a search of Ihor Kolomoiskiy's house
  • pic
    September 27, 2022
    The HACC imposed UAH 40 million bail on Oleksii Kushch
  • pic
    December 2022
    the NABU and the SAPO put Oleksandr Shal, Oleksandra Volovedenko, Bohdan Zhuk, and Pavlo Zvieriev on the wanted list
  • pic
    January 25, 2023
    The HACC arrested Oleksandr Shal in absentia
  • pic
    January 27, 2023
    The HACC arrested Petro Zvieriev in absentia
  • pic
    January 30, 2023
    The HACC arrested Bohdan Zhuk in absentia
  • February 2, 2023
    The HACC arrested Oleksandra Volovedenko in absentia
  • August 1, 2023
    the NABU and the SAPO completed pre-trial investigation in the case

Decisions from the Register

Case No. Court Decision type
991/436/26 HACC 22/01/2026 Decision to cancel the seizure of property
991/6642/23 HACC 02/08/2023
991/6643/23 HACC 02/08/2023
991/6642/23 HACC 02/08/2023
991/6643/23 HACC 02/08/2023
991/5846/23 HACC 04/07/2023 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
991/5846/23 HACC 04/07/2023
991/5846/23 HACC 04/07/2023
991/4281/23 HACC 31/05/2023
991/4281/23 HACC 31/05/2023
991/4034/23 HACC 10/05/2023
991/4034/23 HACC 10/05/2023
991/2439/23 HACC 26/04/2023
991/2439/23 HACC 26/04/2023
991/2337/23 HACC 07/04/2023
991/2337/23 HACC 07/04/2023
991/2401/23 HACC 05/04/2023
991/2401/23 HACC 05/04/2023
991/2489/23 HACC 29/03/2023
991/2489/23 HACC 29/03/2023
991/2228/23 HACC 24/03/2023
991/2228/23 HACC 24/03/2023
991/178/23 CCC 23/03/2023 On the refusal to open cassation proceedings
991/2488/23 HACC 23/03/2023
991/2488/23 HACC 23/03/2023
991/2181/23 HACC 15/03/2023
991/2181/23 HACC 15/03/2023
991/2181/23 HACC 14/03/2023
991/249/23 HACC 28/02/2023 On the imposition of an interim measure in the form of detention
991/249/23 HACC 28/02/2023 On the imposition of an interim measure in the form of detention
991/412/23 HACC 27/02/2023
991/412/23 HACC 27/02/2023
991/1509/23 HACC 22/02/2023
991/410/23 HACC 22/02/2023
991/412/23 HACC 22/02/2023
991/412/23 HACC 22/02/2023
991/410/23 HACC 22/02/2023
991/1509/23 HACC 22/02/2023
991/250/23 HACC 21/02/2023 On the imposition of an interim measure in the form of detention
991/250/23 HACC 21/02/2023 On the imposition of an interim measure in the form of detention
991/250/23 HACC AC 21/02/2023
991/250/23 HACC AC 21/02/2023
991/178/23 HACC AC 14/02/2023 On the refusal to open appeal proceedings
991/248/23 HACC 02/02/2023 On the imposition of an interim measure in the form of detention
991/248/23 HACC 02/02/2023 On the imposition of an interim measure in the form of detention
991/247/23 HACC 31/01/2023 On the imposition of an interim measure in the form of detention
991/410/23 HACC 31/01/2023
991/411/23 HACC 31/01/2023
991/410/23 HACC 31/01/2023
991/411/23 HACC 31/01/2023
991/247/23 HACC 31/01/2023 On the imposition of an interim measure in the form of detention
991/178/23 HACC 25/01/2023
991/178/23 HACC 25/01/2023
991/178/23 HACC 18/01/2023
991/316/23 HACC 18/01/2023
991/178/23 HACC 18/01/2023
991/316/23 HACC 18/01/2023
991/6535/22 HACC 23/12/2022
991/6535/22 HACC 23/12/2022
991/5844/22 HACC 25/11/2022
991/5843/22 HACC 25/11/2022
991/5844/22 HACC 25/11/2022
991/5843/22 HACC 25/11/2022
991/5698/22 HACC 23/11/2022
991/5698/22 HACC 23/11/2022
991/5345/22 HACC 10/11/2022
991/5345/22 HACC 10/11/2022
991/3597/22 HACC AC 08/11/2022
991/3597/22 HACC AC 08/11/2022
991/3597/22 HACC 08/11/2022
991/3597/22 HACC 08/11/2022
991/5013/22 HACC 07/11/2022
991/5015/22 HACC 07/11/2022
991/5014/22 HACC 07/11/2022
991/5015/22 HACC 07/11/2022
991/5013/22 HACC 07/11/2022
991/5014/22 HACC 07/11/2022
991/5089/22 HACC 02/11/2022
991/5089/22 HACC 02/11/2022
991/4883/22 HACC 01/11/2022
991/4884/22 HACC 01/11/2022
991/4883/22 HACC 01/11/2022
991/4884/22 HACC 01/11/2022
991/4463/22 HACC 25/10/2022
991/4460/22 HACC 25/10/2022
991/4463/22 HACC 25/10/2022
991/4460/22 HACC 25/10/2022
991/3937/22 HACC 24/10/2022
991/3937/22 HACC 24/10/2022
991/3937/22 HACC AC 24/10/2022 Decision on partial granting of appeals
991/3937/22 HACC AC 24/10/2022 Decision on partial granting of appeals
991/3593/22 HACC AC 21/10/2022
991/3593/22 HACC AC 21/10/2022
991/3593/22 HACC 21/10/2022
991/3593/22 HACC 21/10/2022
991/3596/22 HACC AC 20/10/2022
991/3596/22 HACC AC 20/10/2022
991/3596/22 HACC 20/10/2022
991/3596/22 HACC 20/10/2022
991/3445/22 HACC 19/10/2022
991/3447/22 HACC 19/10/2022
991/3445/22 HACC 19/10/2022
991/3447/22 HACC 19/10/2022
991/3446/22 HACC 19/10/2022
991/3446/22 HACC 19/10/2022
991/3445/22 HACC AC 19/10/2022
991/3446/22 HACC AC 19/10/2022
991/3447/22 HACC AC 19/10/2022
991/3595/22 HACC AC 19/10/2022
991/3446/22 HACC AC 19/10/2022
991/3595/22 HACC AC 19/10/2022
991/3447/22 HACC AC 19/10/2022
991/3445/22 HACC AC 19/10/2022
991/3595/22 HACC 19/10/2022
991/3595/22 HACC 19/10/2022
991/4131/22 HACC 05/10/2022
991/4131/22 HACC 05/10/2022
991/3811/22 HACC 22/09/2022
991/3600/22 HACC 20/09/2022
991/3600/22 HACC 20/09/2022
991/3811/22 HACC 15/09/2022
991/3812/22 HACC 15/09/2022
991/3811/22 HACC 15/09/2022
991/3812/22 HACC 15/09/2022
991/3744/22 HACC 13/09/2022
991/3746/22 HACC 13/09/2022
991/3745/22 HACC 13/09/2022
991/3742/22 HACC 13/09/2022
991/3743/22 HACC 13/09/2022
991/3746/22 HACC 13/09/2022
991/3745/22 HACC 13/09/2022
991/3742/22 HACC 13/09/2022
991/3744/22 HACC 13/09/2022
991/3743/22 HACC 13/09/2022
991/3446/22 HACC 07/09/2022
991/3447/22 HACC 07/09/2022
991/3447/22 HACC 07/09/2022
991/3446/22 HACC 07/09/2022
991/3445/22 HACC 05/09/2022
991/3387/22 HACC 05/09/2022
991/3445/22 HACC 05/09/2022
991/3386/22 HACC 01/09/2022
991/3386/22 HACC 01/09/2022
991/3367/22 HACC 31/08/2022
991/3367/22 HACC 31/08/2022
991/3365/22 HACC 31/08/2022
991/3366/22 HACC 31/08/2022
991/3363/22 HACC 31/08/2022
991/3366/22 HACC 31/08/2022
991/3365/22 HACC 31/08/2022
991/3363/22 HACC 31/08/2022
991/7072/21 HACC 26/11/2021
991/7072/21 HACC 26/11/2021
991/6104/21 HACC 07/09/2021
991/6104/21 HACC 07/09/2021
991/5235/21 HACC 11/08/2021
991/5235/21 HACC 11/08/2021
991/5237/21 HACC 10/08/2021
991/5236/21 HACC 10/08/2021
991/5237/21 HACC 10/08/2021
991/5236/21 HACC 10/08/2021
991/5235/21 HACC 05/08/2021
991/5235/21 HACC 05/08/2021
991/4831/21 HACC 04/08/2021
991/4831/21 HACC 04/08/2021
991/4834/21 HACC 21/07/2021
991/4834/21 HACC 21/07/2021
991/4799/21 HACC 20/07/2021
991/4800/21 HACC 20/07/2021
991/4800/21 HACC 20/07/2021
991/4799/21 HACC 20/07/2021
991/4798/21 HACC 19/07/2021
991/4797/21 HACC 19/07/2021
991/4797/21 HACC 19/07/2021
991/4798/21 HACC 19/07/2021
991/4312/21 HACC 30/06/2021
991/4312/21 HACC 30/06/2021
991/3327/21 HACC 20/05/2021
991/3326/21 HACC 20/05/2021
991/3328/21 HACC 20/05/2021
991/3327/21 HACC 20/05/2021
991/3326/21 HACC 20/05/2021
991/3328/21 HACC 20/05/2021
991/3215/21 HACC 13/05/2021
991/3217/21 HACC 13/05/2021
991/3218/21 HACC 13/05/2021
991/3216/21 HACC 13/05/2021
991/2450/21 HACC 13/04/2021
991/2450/21 HACC 13/04/2021
991/2450/21 HACC 09/04/2021
991/2006/21 HACC 24/03/2021
991/2007/21 HACC 24/03/2021
991/2005/21 HACC 24/03/2021
991/2009/21 HACC 24/03/2021
991/2007/21 HACC 24/03/2021
991/2006/21 HACC 24/03/2021
991/2005/21 HACC 24/03/2021
991/2009/21 HACC 24/03/2021
991/611/21 HACC 16/03/2021
991/611/21 HACC 16/03/2021
991/1475/21 HACC 15/03/2021
991/1475/21 HACC 15/03/2021
991/1274/21 HACC 12/03/2021
991/1274/21 HACC 12/03/2021
991/1274/21 HACC 11/03/2021
991/1274/21 HACC 04/03/2021
991/1335/21 HACC 04/03/2021
991/1334/21 HACC 04/03/2021
991/1335/21 HACC 04/03/2021
991/1334/21 HACC 04/03/2021
991/1274/21 HACC 01/03/2021
991/1335/21 HACC 24/02/2021
991/1334/21 HACC 24/02/2021
991/780/21 HACC AC 18/02/2021
991/780/21 HACC AC 18/02/2021
991/654/21 HACC 04/02/2021
991/655/21 HACC 04/02/2021
991/780/21 HACC 04/02/2021
991/484/21 HACC 04/02/2021
991/655/21 HACC 04/02/2021
991/654/21 HACC 04/02/2021
991/654/21 HACC 02/02/2021
991/655/21 HACC 02/02/2021
991/656/21 HACC 02/02/2021
991/396/21 HACC 27/01/2021
991/396/21 HACC 27/01/2021
991/400/21 HACC 26/01/2021 Complaint about the non-compliance with reasonable time limits during pre-trial investigation in criminal proceedings
991/400/21 HACC 26/01/2021 Complaint about the non-compliance with reasonable time limits during pre-trial investigation in criminal proceedings
991/400/21 HACC 21/01/2021
991/10049/20 HACC 22/12/2020
991/10049/20 HACC 22/12/2020
991/10049/20 HACC 18/12/2020
991/9974/20 HACC 14/12/2020
991/9974/20 HACC 14/12/2020
991/10049/20 HACC 09/12/2020
760/24541/19 CCC 07/12/2020 On the refusal to open cassation proceedings
760/24541/19 CCC 23/11/2020
760/24541/19 CCC 23/11/2020 On leaving the cassation appeal without motion
760/24541/19 HACC AC 17/11/2020 On the refusal to open appeal proceedings
760/24541/19 CCC 09/11/2020 On the refusal to open cassation proceedings
991/7604/20 HACC AC 29/10/2020 On the refusal to open appeal proceedings
991/5784/20 HACC 12/10/2020
991/5784/20 HACC 12/10/2020
991/5784/20 HACC 07/10/2020
991/7604/20 HACC 06/10/2020
991/7604/20 HACC 06/10/2020
991/5784/20 HACC 02/10/2020
991/5784/20 HACC 10/09/2020
991/7604/20 HACC 10/09/2020
991/5784/20 HACC 07/09/2020
991/6286/20 HACC 19/08/2020
991/6285/20 HACC 04/08/2020
991/6285/20 HACC 04/08/2020
991/5784/20 HACC 28/07/2020
991/5784/20 HACC 21/07/2020
991/5784/20 HACC 20/07/2020
991/5784/20 HACC 16/07/2020
991/5784/20 HACC 14/07/2020
991/3568/20 HACC 15/06/2020
991/3568/20 HACC 15/06/2020
991/3568/20 HACC 12/06/2020
991/3568/20 HACC 04/06/2020
991/3568/20 HACC 29/05/2020
991/3568/20 HACC 27/05/2020
991/3568/20 HACC 25/05/2020
760/24541/19 CCC 20/05/2020
991/786/20 HACC AC 13/05/2020 On the refusal to open appeal proceedings
991/3568/20 HACC 08/05/2020
991/3568/20 HACC 06/05/2020
991/786/20 HACC 09/04/2020
991/786/20 HACC 09/04/2020
757/47095/19-к CCC 08/04/2020
991/2171/20 HACC 23/03/2020
991/2171/20 HACC 23/03/2020
991/2171/20 HACC 12/03/2020
757/47095/19-к CCC 02/03/2020 On the completion of preparation and appointment of the cassation hearing
991/1234/20 HACC 13/02/2020
991/786/20 HACC 10/02/2020
991/1234/20 HACC 10/02/2020
991/786/20 HACC 10/02/2020
4910/60/19 HACC 21/01/2020
4910/60/19 HACC 21/01/2020
4910/60/19 HACC 21/01/2020
4910/60/19 HACC 21/01/2020
4910/60/19 HACC 28/12/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 03/12/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 13/11/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 13/11/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 13/11/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 13/11/2019
760/7677/19 HACC AC 11/11/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 05/11/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 05/11/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 05/11/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 05/11/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 05/11/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 05/11/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 04/11/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 04/11/2019
760/32037/18 HACC AC 04/11/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 04/11/2019
760/32037/18 HACC AC 04/11/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 01/11/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 01/11/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 01/11/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 01/11/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 01/11/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 31/10/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 31/10/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 31/10/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 25/10/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 23/10/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 22/10/2019
4910/60/19 CCC 21/10/2019 On the refusal to open cassation proceedings
4910/60/19 HACC 16/10/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 07/10/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 03/10/2019
4910/60/19 HACC AC 03/10/2019 On the refusal to open appeal proceedings
760/7677/19 HACC AC 01/10/2019
760/32037/18 HACC AC 25/09/2019
757/47095/19-к HACC AC 24/09/2019 On the return of the appeal
760/32037/18 HACC AC 19/09/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 16/09/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 16/09/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 13/09/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 13/09/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 11/09/2019
4910/60/19 HACC 11/09/2019