Search

The case of Vadym Alperin, the “king of smuggling” and Odesa-based businessman

  • Date of commencement of the case: 10/08/2022
Track case progress If you would like to follow the case, leave your email and get updates sent straight to your inbox
The case of Vadym Alperin, the “king of smuggling” and Odesa-based businessman The case of Vadym Alperin, the “king of smuggling” and Odesa-based businessman

Case description

The NABU and the SAPO accuse Vadym Alperin, Odesa-based businessman, of organizing a scheme to smuggle goods across the Ukrainian border. The state suffered over UAH 60 million in losses.

According to the prosecution, in mid-2016, Alperin established a criminal organization with structural units in Odesa and Kyiv. The group was joined by Alina Skomarova, former Director of the SFS Department; Serhii Tupalskyi, Deputy Chairman of Kyiv Customs; Alperin's colleagues Oleh Sebov and Yevhenii Iskold; and Serhii Shkuratov, a representative of private companies at the customs. 

Alperin assigned the following tasks to the organization's members: importing textiles and light industry goods into Ukraine; acquiring or creating potential importing companies; delivering these goods to the customs office; bribing customs officials; paying understated customs duties to release these goods into circulation; filing customs declarations with understated customs values; and obtaining court decisions to adjust such understated customs values.

Representatives of private enterprises filed customs declarations with an understated value of imported property. After that, Kyiv customs officials formally refused to accept the declared value, and then adjusted it without complying with the law. 

As a result, representatives of the companies filed claims to cancel such judgments with the Odesa District Administrative Court. Judges were forced to grant such claims, and as a result, the goods were cleared at a reduced value. 

In September 2017, the NABU initiated the seizure of more than UAH 450 million of funds of the companies involved in the fraud. Later, in December 2017, Alperin offered the NABU detectives a bribe of USD 800,000 to stop investigating the case and hand it over to the police, but the businessman was caught red-handed. 

The defendants' actions were classified under Article 255(1), Article 212(3), Article 364(2) of the Criminal Code of Ukraine.

In 2019, Volodymyr Zelenskyy even promised a valuable gift to NABU employees who would detain the businessman. In April 2021, Alperin was deprived of his citizenship, and later the National Security and Defense Council imposed personal sanctions on him.

  • Proceeding No.: 52017000000000636
  • Case No.: 991/2892/22 show all cases hide other cases
  • Other court cases No.: 991/2177/19, 991/3/20, 991/63/20, 991/151/20, 991/497/20, 991/496/20, 991/495/20, 991/506/20, 991/508/20, 991/507/20, 991/527/20, 991/560/20, 991/523/20, 991/525/20, 991/526/20, 991/743/20, 991/290/20, 991/518/20, 991/1114/20, 991/1864/20, 991/1603/20, 991/2114/20, 991/2204/20, 991/2205/20, 991/2304/20, 991/2306/20, 991/2301/20, 991/2308/20, 991/2305/20, 991/2302/20, 991/2278/20, 991/2300/20, 991/2303/20, 991/2307/20, 991/1799/20, 991/2257/20, 991/2394/20, 991/1602/20, 991/2581/20, 991/2530/20, 991/2468/20, 991/2467/20, 991/2660/20, 991/2532/20, 991/1883/20, 991/2617/20, 991/3434/20, 991/3752/20, 991/3753/20, 991/3769/20, 991/3765/20, 991/3767/20, 991/3754/20, 991/3770/20, 991/3783/20, 991/3768/20, 991/3766/20, 991/3473/20, 991/4090/20, 991/3920/20, 991/4181/20, 991/4234/20, 991/4235/20, 991/4227/20, 991/4526/20, 991/4517/20, 991/5171/20, 991/5170/20, 991/5200/20, 991/5494/20, 991/5495/20, 991/5639/20, 991/5663/20, 991/5662/20, 991/5684/20, 991/5758/20, 991/5819/20, 991/5638/20, 991/5818/20, 991/5816/20, 991/6288/20, 991/6647/20, 991/6742/20, 991/6559/20, 991/7029/20, 991/6989/20, 991/7026/20, 991/7027/20, 991/7028/20, 991/6990/20, 991/6988/20, 991/6991/20, 991/7157/20, 991/7473/20, 991/7475/20, 991/7830/20, 991/7807/20, 991/7877/20, 991/8593/20, 991/8633/20, 991/8558/20, 991/8636/20, 991/8677/20, 991/8974/20, 991/9562/20, 991/9563/20, 991/9564/20, 991/9565/20, 991/9586/20, 991/9765/20, 991/9943/20, 991/9888/20, 991/10421/20, 991/10422/20, 991/186/21, 991/185/21, 991/234/21, 991/305/21, 991/306/21, 991/326/21, 991/325/21, 991/401/21, 991/380/21, 991/460/21, 991/581/21, 991/580/21, 991/659/21, 991/730/21, 991/737/21, 991/812/21, 991/813/21, 991/1791/21, 991/1816/21, 991/1821/21, 991/2016/21, 991/2053/21, 991/2260/21, 991/2432/21, 991/2874/21, 991/2631/21, 991/3116/21, 991/3174/21, 991/3175/21, 991/3176/21, 991/3603/21, 991/3279/21, 991/4552/21, 991/4586/21, 991/4585/21, 991/4483/21, 991/4844/21, 991/4953/21, 991/5437/21, 991/5551/21, 991/5867/21, 991/6018/21, 991/6017/21, 991/6005/21, 991/6019/21, 991/6514/21, 991/6777/21, 991/7110/21, 991/7333/21, 991/7332/21, 991/7268/21, 991/7313/21, 991/7872/21, 991/8072/21, 991/8083/21, 991/8199/21, 991/8565/21, 991/8564/21, 991/8543/21, 991/8545/21, 991/8544/21, 991/8542/21, 991/401/22, 991/403/22, 991/402/22, 991/147/22, 991/1133/22, 991/1132/22, 991/1725/22, 991/2124/22, 991/2548/22, 991/2631/22, 991/2726/22, 991/2707/22, 991/2662/22, 991/2652/22, 991/2755/22, 991/2873/22
  • Incriminated: Article 364, part 2, Article 368, part 3, Article 369, part 3, Article 364, part 1, Article 191, part 5
Instance Key parties Instance /Key parties:
HACC AC
06/11/2023

Panel of judges: Semennykov O.Yu., Bodnar S.B.

HACC
10/08/2022

Panel of judges: Salandiak O.Ya., Movchan N.V., Kravchuk O.O.

CCC
19/03/2020

Panel of judges: Storozhenko S.O., Borodii V.M., Ivanenko I.V., Kovtunovych M.I., Borodii V.M., Yeremeichuk S.V., Mazur M.V., Chystyk A.O., Buleiko O.L., Fomin S.B., Vus S.M., Ivanenko I.V., Luhanskyi Yu.M.

HACC
28/11/2019

Panel of judges: Movchan N.V., Moisak S.M., Voronko V.D., Oliinyk O.V., Khamzin T.R., Moisak S.M.

Lawyer: Martynenka I.O., Dikoho S.M., Hovorukhy M.M., Lupashko D.A., Stanishevskoho Ye.V., Lychmaniuka A.V., Barbuly O.O., Kholodyla P.V., Lahomina A.A., Anapriiuk A.S., Shchyruk M.M., Lysaka O.M., Demchenko K.M., Fedur A.A., Yanchenko S.P., Dzhevahy M.V., Mikhalova A.O., Kutsa Ya.O., Malomanova I.V.

Prosecutor: Semak I.A., Harvanko I.M., Skybenko O.I., Symkiv R.Ya., Perov A.V.

Infographics

THE CASE OF VADYM ALPERIN

Vadym Alperin, the "king of smuggling," allegedly organized a scheme to smuggle goods into Ukraine. The national budget lost more than UAH 60 million due to customs clearance fraud.

  • 2016-2017
    Alperin's scheme for importing goods across the border at a reduced customs value was in operation
  • September 2017
    the NABU started investigating Alperin's case
  • December 2017
    Alperin offered a bribe of USD 800,000 to a NABU detective
  • pic
    November 27, 2019
    The NABU served Alperin and other defendants with suspicion notices
  • November 28, 2019
    The HACC imposed an interim measure in the form of night-time house arrest on Tupalskyi and Skomarova
  • pic
    November 29, 2019
    The HACC took Iskold into custody with an alternative of bail in the amount of UAH 576,300
  • pic
    November 29, 2019
    The HACC took Sebov into custody with an alternative of more than UAH 18 million bail
  • pic
    November 29, 2019
    The HACC took Alperin into custody with an alternative of UAH 70 million bail
  • November 16, 2020
    The NABU completed an investigation in the case
  • April 14, 2021
    Volodymyr Zelenskyy deprived Alperin of his citizenship
  • August 9, 2022
    the SAPO referred an indictment to the HACC
  • pic
    October 12, 2023
    The HACC closed Alperin's case due to the "Lozovyi’s amendments."
  • pic
    March 22, 2024
    The HACC Appeals Chamber overturned the closure of the case and referred the case for a new hearing to the HACC
  • April 4, 2024
    Volodymyr Zelenskyy signed a decree imposing personal sanctions on Alperin and others by the National Security and Defense Council

Decisions from the Register

Case No. Court Decision date Decision type
991/2177/19 HACC 28/11/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 28/11/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 28/11/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 28/11/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 28/11/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 28/11/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 28/11/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 28/11/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 28/11/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 29/11/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 29/11/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 29/11/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 29/11/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 29/11/2019 On the imposition of an interim measure in the form of detention
991/2177/19 HACC 29/11/2019 On the imposition of an interim measure in the form of detention
991/2177/19 HACC 29/11/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 29/11/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 03/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC AC 03/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC AC 03/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC AC 03/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC AC 03/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC AC 03/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC AC 03/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 03/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 04/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC AC 04/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC AC 04/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 04/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC AC 06/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC AC 06/12/2019 On the imposition of an interim measure in the form of detention
991/2177/19 HACC AC 06/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC AC 06/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC AC 06/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC AC 09/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 10/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 10/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 10/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 11/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC AC 11/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC AC 12/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC AC 12/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC AC 13/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC AC 16/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 16/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 16/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 17/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 17/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 17/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 17/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 17/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 17/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 17/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 17/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 17/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 17/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC AC 18/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC AC 18/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC 18/12/2019
991/2177/19 HACC AC 28/12/2019 On the return of the appeal
991/3/20 HACC 02/01/2020
991/2177/19 HACC AC 02/01/2020
991/2177/19 HACC AC 03/01/2020
991/2177/19 HACC AC 03/01/2020 On closing appeal proceedings
991/2177/19 HACC AC 08/01/2020
991/63/20 HACC 08/01/2020
991/63/20 HACC 08/01/2020
991/3/20 HACC 10/01/2020
991/2177/19 HACC AC 13/01/2020
991/151/20 HACC 17/01/2020
991/497/20 HACC 20/01/2020
991/496/20 HACC 20/01/2020
991/495/20 HACC 20/01/2020
991/496/20 HACC 20/01/2020
991/497/20 HACC 20/01/2020
991/495/20 HACC 20/01/2020
991/506/20 HACC 21/01/2020
991/508/20 HACC 21/01/2020
991/507/20 HACC 21/01/2020
991/506/20 HACC 21/01/2020
991/508/20 HACC 21/01/2020
991/507/20 HACC 21/01/2020
991/527/20 HACC 22/01/2020
991/560/20 HACC 22/01/2020
991/523/20 HACC 22/01/2020 On changing the interim measure for the accused
991/525/20 HACC 22/01/2020
991/560/20 HACC 22/01/2020
991/527/20 HACC 22/01/2020
991/526/20 HACC 23/01/2020
991/526/20 HACC 23/01/2020
991/2177/19 HACC 28/01/2020
991/2177/19 HACC 28/01/2020
991/2177/19 HACC AC 28/01/2020
991/2177/19 HACC AC 31/01/2020 On the return of the appeal
991/2177/19 HACC 18/02/2020
991/2177/19 HACC 18/02/2020
991/743/20 HACC AC 18/02/2020
991/2177/19 HACC AC 18/02/2020
991/2177/19 HACC AC 18/02/2020
991/2177/19 HACC AC 18/02/2020
991/290/20 HACC 19/02/2020
991/290/20 HACC AC 24/02/2020
991/518/20 HACC 26/02/2020
991/1114/20 HACC 26/02/2020
991/1114/20 HACC 26/02/2020
991/1864/20 HACC 03/03/2020
991/743/20 HACC 10/03/2020
991/743/20 HACC 10/03/2020
991/743/20 HACC AC 10/03/2020
991/743/20 HACC AC 10/03/2020
991/290/20 HACC AC 10/03/2020
991/290/20 HACC AC 10/03/2020
991/743/20 HACC AC 10/03/2020
991/1603/20 HACC 11/03/2020
991/2114/20 HACC 12/03/2020
991/2114/20 HACC 16/03/2020
991/2204/20 HACC 16/03/2020
991/2205/20 HACC 16/03/2020
991/2304/20 HACC 17/03/2020
991/2306/20 HACC 17/03/2020
991/2301/20 HACC 17/03/2020
991/2304/20 HACC 17/03/2020
991/2306/20 HACC 17/03/2020
991/1114/20 HACC 18/03/2020
991/1114/20 HACC 18/03/2020
991/2308/20 HACC 19/03/2020
991/2305/20 HACC 19/03/2020
991/2305/20 HACC 19/03/2020
991/2302/20 HACC 19/03/2020
991/2278/20 HACC 19/03/2020
991/2308/20 HACC 19/03/2020
991/2305/20 HACC 19/03/2020
991/2302/20 HACC 19/03/2020
991/2177/19 CCC 19/03/2020 On the refusal to open cassation proceedings
991/2177/19 CCC 19/03/2020 On the refusal to open cassation proceedings
991/2300/20 HACC 20/03/2020
991/2303/20 HACC 20/03/2020
991/2307/20 HACC 20/03/2020
991/2300/20 HACC 20/03/2020
991/2303/20 HACC 20/03/2020
991/1799/20 HACC 20/03/2020
991/2303/20 HACC 20/03/2020
991/2307/20 HACC 20/03/2020
991/2303/20 HACC 20/03/2020
991/2300/20 HACC 20/03/2020
991/2257/20 HACC 23/03/2020
991/2278/20 HACC 23/03/2020
991/2394/20 HACC 23/03/2020
991/2394/20 HACC 23/03/2020
991/1602/20 HACC 24/03/2020
991/1114/20 HACC AC 25/03/2020
991/1799/20 HACC 27/03/2020
991/1799/20 HACC AC 27/03/2020 On the return of the appeal
991/2581/20 HACC 31/03/2020
991/2581/20 HACC 31/03/2020
991/2530/20 HACC 31/03/2020
991/2468/20 HACC 07/04/2020
991/2467/20 HACC 08/04/2020
991/2581/20 HACC 10/04/2020
991/2468/20 HACC 13/04/2020
991/2468/20 HACC 13/04/2020
991/2660/20 HACC 14/04/2020
991/1114/20 HACC AC 16/04/2020
991/2532/20 HACC 17/04/2020
991/1883/20 HACC 27/04/2020
991/1883/20 HACC 27/04/2020
991/2257/20 HACC 28/04/2020
991/2617/20 HACC 29/04/2020
991/3434/20 HACC 13/05/2020
991/3434/20 HACC 13/05/2020
991/3752/20 HACC 14/05/2020
991/3753/20 HACC 14/05/2020
991/3753/20 HACC 14/05/2020
991/3752/20 HACC 14/05/2020
991/3769/20 HACC 15/05/2020
991/3765/20 HACC 15/05/2020
991/3767/20 HACC 15/05/2020
991/3769/20 HACC 15/05/2020
991/3767/20 HACC 15/05/2020
991/3765/20 HACC 18/05/2020
991/3754/20 HACC 18/05/2020
991/3770/20 HACC 18/05/2020
991/3783/20 HACC 18/05/2020
991/3754/20 HACC 18/05/2020
991/3765/20 HACC 18/05/2020
991/3768/20 HACC 19/05/2020
991/3770/20 HACC 19/05/2020
991/3766/20 HACC 19/05/2020
991/3473/20 HACC 19/05/2020
991/3768/20 HACC 19/05/2020
991/3473/20 HACC 19/05/2020
991/3770/20 HACC 19/05/2020
991/4090/20 HACC 21/05/2020
991/3766/20 HACC 21/05/2020
991/3783/20 HACC 21/05/2020
991/3766/20 HACC 21/05/2020
991/3920/20 HACC 22/05/2020 On changing the interim measure for the accused
991/3920/20 HACC 22/05/2020 On changing the interim measure for the accused
991/4090/20 HACC 25/05/2020
991/4090/20 HACC 25/05/2020
991/4181/20 HACC 27/05/2020
991/4181/20 HACC 28/05/2020
991/4234/20 HACC 29/05/2020
991/4181/20 HACC 29/05/2020
991/1114/20 CCC 01/06/2020 On the refusal to open cassation proceedings
991/4181/20 HACC 02/06/2020 On changing the interim measure for the accused
991/4181/20 HACC 02/06/2020 On changing the interim measure for the accused
991/1114/20 HACC AC 03/06/2020
991/4235/20 HACC 09/06/2020
991/4227/20 HACC 10/06/2020
991/4526/20 HACC 12/06/2020 Decision on temporary access
991/4526/20 HACC 12/06/2020 Decision on temporary access
991/290/20 CCC 15/06/2020 On the refusal to open cassation proceedings
991/4517/20 HACC 16/06/2020
991/4227/20 HACC 16/06/2020
991/4227/20 HACC 16/06/2020
991/4235/20 HACC 22/06/2020
991/4235/20 HACC 22/06/2020
991/5171/20 HACC 25/06/2020
991/5170/20 HACC 25/06/2020
991/5200/20 HACC 25/06/2020
991/1114/20 HACC AC 30/06/2020
991/1114/20 HACC AC 30/06/2020
991/4517/20 HACC 02/07/2020
991/4517/20 HACC 02/07/2020
991/5494/20 HACC 06/07/2020
991/5495/20 HACC 06/07/2020
991/4227/20 HACC 08/07/2020
991/4227/20 HACC 08/07/2020
991/5639/20 HACC 10/07/2020
991/5663/20 HACC 10/07/2020
991/5662/20 HACC 10/07/2020
991/5639/20 HACC 10/07/2020
991/5662/20 HACC 10/07/2020
991/5663/20 HACC 10/07/2020
991/5684/20 HACC 14/07/2020
991/5758/20 HACC 14/07/2020
991/5684/20 HACC 14/07/2020
991/5758/20 HACC 14/07/2020
991/5819/20 HACC 15/07/2020
991/5638/20 HACC 16/07/2020
991/5818/20 HACC 16/07/2020
991/5638/20 HACC 16/07/2020
991/5816/20 HACC 17/07/2020
991/5819/20 HACC 17/07/2020
991/5818/20 HACC 17/07/2020
991/5819/20 HACC 17/07/2020
991/5818/20 HACC 17/07/2020
991/5816/20 HACC 17/07/2020
991/6288/20 HACC 30/07/2020
991/6288/20 HACC 31/07/2020
991/6288/20 HACC 31/07/2020
991/6647/20 HACC 07/08/2020
991/6742/20 HACC 12/08/2020
991/6742/20 HACC 17/08/2020
991/6559/20 HACC 17/08/2020
991/6742/20 HACC 17/08/2020
991/7029/20 HACC 20/08/2020
991/6989/20 HACC 20/08/2020
991/7026/20 HACC 20/08/2020
991/6559/20 HACC 20/08/2020
991/7027/20 HACC 20/08/2020
991/7028/20 HACC 20/08/2020
991/7026/20 HACC 20/08/2020
991/7028/20 HACC 20/08/2020
991/7029/20 HACC 20/08/2020
991/7027/20 HACC 20/08/2020
991/6559/20 HACC 20/08/2020
991/6990/20 HACC 21/08/2020
991/6988/20 HACC 21/08/2020
991/6989/20 HACC 21/08/2020
991/6989/20 HACC 21/08/2020
991/6988/20 HACC 25/08/2020
991/6991/20 HACC 25/08/2020
991/6990/20 HACC 25/08/2020
991/6990/20 HACC 25/08/2020
991/6991/20 HACC 25/08/2020
991/6988/20 HACC 25/08/2020
991/7157/20 HACC 26/08/2020
991/7157/20 HACC 27/08/2020
991/7157/20 HACC 27/08/2020
991/7473/20 HACC 09/09/2020
991/7475/20 HACC 09/09/2020
991/7475/20 HACC 10/09/2020
991/7475/20 HACC 10/09/2020
991/7473/20 HACC 11/09/2020
991/7830/20 HACC 22/09/2020
991/7807/20 HACC 23/09/2020
991/7877/20 HACC 23/09/2020
991/7877/20 HACC 23/09/2020
991/7807/20 HACC 23/09/2020
991/7830/20 HACC 29/09/2020
991/7877/20 HACC AC 01/10/2020
991/7877/20 HACC AC 05/10/2020
991/8593/20 HACC 19/10/2020
991/8593/20 HACC 20/10/2020
991/8633/20 HACC 20/10/2020
991/8558/20 HACC 20/10/2020
991/8636/20 HACC 20/10/2020
991/8593/20 HACC 20/10/2020
991/8558/20 HACC 20/10/2020
991/8633/20 HACC 21/10/2020
991/8633/20 HACC 21/10/2020
991/8636/20 HACC 22/10/2020
991/8677/20 HACC 22/10/2020
991/8677/20 HACC 22/10/2020
991/8636/20 HACC 22/10/2020
991/7877/20 HACC 02/11/2020
991/7877/20 HACC 02/11/2020
991/7877/20 HACC AC 02/11/2020
991/8974/20 HACC 02/11/2020
991/7877/20 HACC AC 02/11/2020
991/7877/20 HACC AC 02/11/2020
991/8974/20 HACC 03/11/2020
991/8974/20 HACC 03/11/2020
991/9562/20 HACC 20/11/2020
991/9563/20 HACC 20/11/2020
991/9564/20 HACC 23/11/2020
991/9562/20 HACC 23/11/2020
991/9563/20 HACC 23/11/2020
991/9565/20 HACC 23/11/2020
991/9562/20 HACC 23/11/2020
991/9565/20 HACC 23/11/2020
991/9563/20 HACC 23/11/2020
991/9562/20 HACC 24/11/2020
991/9562/20 HACC 24/11/2020
991/9562/20 HACC 24/11/2020
991/9564/20 HACC 24/11/2020
991/9562/20 HACC 24/11/2020
991/9564/20 HACC 24/11/2020
991/9562/20 HACC 24/11/2020
991/9564/20 HACC 24/11/2020
991/9564/20 HACC 25/11/2020
991/9564/20 HACC 25/11/2020
991/9586/20 HACC 25/11/2020
991/9562/20 HACC 25/11/2020
991/9564/20 HACC 25/11/2020
991/9564/20 HACC 25/11/2020
991/9562/20 HACC 25/11/2020
991/9586/20 HACC 25/11/2020
991/9564/20 HACC 25/11/2020
991/9765/20 HACC 27/11/2020
991/9943/20 HACC 03/12/2020
991/9943/20 HACC 03/12/2020
991/9943/20 HACC 04/12/2020
991/9888/20 HACC 07/12/2020
991/9564/20 CCC 15/12/2020 On the refusal to open cassation proceedings
991/9888/20 HACC 16/12/2020
991/10421/20 HACC 22/12/2020
991/10422/20 HACC 22/12/2020
991/10421/20 HACC 23/12/2020
991/10422/20 HACC 23/12/2020
991/2177/19 HACC AC 23/12/2020
991/10421/20 HACC 24/12/2020
991/10422/20 HACC 24/12/2020
991/10421/20 HACC 24/12/2020
991/10422/20 HACC 24/12/2020
991/9564/20 HACC AC 11/01/2021 On the return of the appeal
991/2177/19 CCC 12/01/2021 On the refusal to open cassation proceedings
991/186/21 HACC 13/01/2021
991/185/21 HACC 13/01/2021
991/185/21 HACC 14/01/2021
991/186/21 HACC 14/01/2021
991/186/21 HACC 15/01/2021
991/185/21 HACC 15/01/2021
991/186/21 HACC 15/01/2021
991/234/21 HACC 18/01/2021
991/305/21 HACC 18/01/2021
991/234/21 HACC 18/01/2021
991/305/21 HACC 19/01/2021
991/305/21 HACC 19/01/2021
991/306/21 HACC 20/01/2021
991/326/21 HACC 20/01/2021
991/325/21 HACC 20/01/2021
991/325/21 HACC 20/01/2021
991/326/21 HACC 21/01/2021
991/326/21 HACC 21/01/2021
991/401/21 HACC 26/01/2021
991/380/21 HACC 26/01/2021
991/460/21 HACC 26/01/2021
991/401/21 HACC 26/01/2021
991/306/21 HACC 27/01/2021
991/581/21 HACC 28/01/2021
991/580/21 HACC 28/01/2021
991/580/21 HACC 29/01/2021
991/581/21 HACC 29/01/2021
991/580/21 HACC 29/01/2021
991/659/21 HACC 02/02/2021
991/730/21 HACC 04/02/2021
991/460/21 HACC AC 04/02/2021
991/737/21 HACC 04/02/2021
991/812/21 HACC 05/02/2021
991/813/21 HACC 05/02/2021
991/730/21 HACC 08/02/2021 On changing the interim measure for the accused
991/460/21 HACC AC 08/02/2021
991/460/21 HACC AC 08/02/2021
991/730/21 HACC 08/02/2021 On changing the interim measure for the accused
991/9564/20 CCC 08/02/2021 On the refusal to open cassation proceedings
991/812/21 HACC 09/02/2021
991/813/21 HACC 09/02/2021
991/813/21 HACC 09/02/2021
991/812/21 HACC 09/02/2021
991/659/21 HACC 10/02/2021 On changing the interim measure for the accused
991/659/21 HACC 10/02/2021 On changing the interim measure for the accused
991/813/21 HACC AC 15/02/2021
991/813/21 HACC AC 16/02/2021 On closing appeal proceedings
991/813/21 HACC AC 16/02/2021 On closing appeal proceedings
991/813/21 HACC AC 16/02/2021
991/2177/19 HACC 04/03/2021
991/813/21 HACC 11/03/2021
991/1791/21 HACC 12/03/2021
991/1791/21 HACC 15/03/2021
991/1816/21 HACC 16/03/2021
991/1791/21 HACC 16/03/2021
991/1821/21 HACC 16/03/2021
991/1791/21 HACC 16/03/2021
991/1816/21 HACC 16/03/2021
991/1821/21 HACC 17/03/2021
991/1821/21 HACC 17/03/2021
991/2016/21 HACC 24/03/2021
991/2053/21 HACC 26/03/2021
991/2053/21 HACC 29/03/2021 On changing the interim measure for the accused
991/2053/21 HACC 29/03/2021 On changing the interim measure for the accused
991/813/21 CCC 29/03/2021 On the refusal to open cassation proceedings
991/2260/21 HACC 02/04/2021
991/2260/21 HACC 05/04/2021
991/2016/21 HACC 05/04/2021
991/2260/21 HACC 05/04/2021
991/2016/21 HACC 05/04/2021
991/2432/21 HACC 09/04/2021
991/2432/21 HACC 09/04/2021
991/2874/21 HACC 27/04/2021
991/2874/21 HACC 27/04/2021 On changing the interim measure for the accused
991/2631/21 HACC 27/04/2021
991/2874/21 HACC 27/04/2021 On changing the interim measure for the accused
991/3116/21 HACC 06/05/2021
991/3116/21 HACC 11/05/2021 On changing the interim measure for the accused
991/3116/21 HACC 11/05/2021 On changing the interim measure for the accused
991/3174/21 HACC 12/05/2021
991/3175/21 HACC 13/05/2021
991/3174/21 HACC 13/05/2021
991/3175/21 HACC 13/05/2021
991/3176/21 HACC 13/05/2021
991/3175/21 HACC 13/05/2021
991/3176/21 HACC 13/05/2021
991/3174/21 HACC 13/05/2021
991/3603/21 HACC 28/05/2021
991/3603/21 HACC 31/05/2021
991/3279/21 HACC AC 31/05/2021
991/3603/21 HACC 31/05/2021
991/3279/21 HACC AC 03/06/2021
991/3279/21 HACC AC 03/06/2021
991/4552/21 HACC 07/07/2021
991/4586/21 HACC 08/07/2021
991/4552/21 HACC 09/07/2021
991/4586/21 HACC 09/07/2021
991/4552/21 HACC 09/07/2021
991/4586/21 HACC 09/07/2021
991/4585/21 HACC 12/07/2021
991/4585/21 HACC 12/07/2021
991/4483/21 HACC 14/07/2021
991/4844/21 HACC 22/07/2021
991/4844/21 HACC 23/07/2021
991/4844/21 HACC 23/07/2021
991/4953/21 HACC 26/07/2021
991/5437/21 HACC 18/08/2021
991/5437/21 HACC 18/08/2021
991/5551/21 HACC AC 26/08/2021
991/5867/21 HACC 30/08/2021
991/5867/21 HACC 31/08/2021
991/5867/21 HACC 31/08/2021
991/6018/21 HACC 03/09/2021
991/6017/21 HACC 03/09/2021
991/6005/21 HACC 06/09/2021
991/6017/21 HACC 06/09/2021
991/6018/21 HACC 06/09/2021
991/6005/21 HACC 06/09/2021
991/6017/21 HACC 06/09/2021
991/6018/21 HACC 06/09/2021
991/6019/21 HACC 07/09/2021
991/6019/21 HACC 07/09/2021
991/6514/21 HACC 22/09/2021
991/6514/21 HACC 22/09/2021
991/6514/21 HACC 22/09/2021
991/5551/21 HACC AC 22/09/2021
991/6514/21 HACC 05/10/2021
991/6514/21 HACC 05/10/2021
991/6777/21 HACC 05/10/2021
991/6514/21 HACC 05/10/2021
991/5551/21 CCC 18/10/2021 On the refusal to open cassation proceedings
991/7110/21 HACC 26/10/2021 Decision on temporary access
991/7110/21 HACC 26/10/2021 Decision on temporary access
991/7333/21 HACC 29/10/2021
991/7332/21 HACC 01/11/2021
991/7333/21 HACC 01/11/2021
991/7332/21 HACC 01/11/2021
991/7333/21 HACC 01/11/2021
991/7332/21 HACC 01/11/2021
991/7268/21 HACC 03/11/2021
991/7268/21 HACC 03/11/2021
991/7313/21 HACC 04/11/2021 Decision on temporary access
991/7313/21 HACC 04/11/2021 Decision on temporary access
991/7872/21 HACC 22/11/2021
991/7872/21 HACC 24/11/2021 On changing the interim measure for the accused
991/7872/21 HACC 24/11/2021 On changing the interim measure for the accused
991/8072/21 HACC 29/11/2021
991/8083/21 HACC 02/12/2021 On changing the interim measure for the accused
991/8199/21 HACC 02/12/2021
991/8083/21 HACC 02/12/2021 On changing the interim measure for the accused
991/8072/21 HACC 07/12/2021
991/8072/21 HACC 07/12/2021
991/8565/21 HACC 21/12/2021
991/8564/21 HACC 22/12/2021
991/8564/21 HACC 24/12/2021
991/8565/21 HACC 24/12/2021
991/8565/21 HACC 24/12/2021
991/8564/21 HACC 24/12/2021
991/8543/21 HACC 29/12/2021
991/8545/21 HACC 29/12/2021
991/8544/21 HACC 29/12/2021
991/8542/21 HACC 29/12/2021
991/401/22 HACC 01/02/2022
991/403/22 HACC 01/02/2022
991/402/22 HACC 01/02/2022
991/147/22 HACC 02/02/2022
991/1133/22 HACC 18/02/2022
991/1132/22 HACC 18/02/2022
991/1133/22 HACC 21/02/2022
991/1132/22 HACC 21/02/2022
991/1133/22 HACC 21/02/2022
991/1132/22 HACC 21/02/2022
991/1725/22 HACC 03/06/2022
991/2124/22 HACC 13/07/2022
991/2124/22 HACC 13/07/2022
991/2548/22 HACC 20/07/2022
991/2631/22 HACC 27/07/2022
991/2726/22 HACC 29/07/2022
991/2707/22 HACC 29/07/2022
991/2662/22 HACC 01/08/2022
991/2652/22 HACC AC 01/08/2022
991/2755/22 HACC 01/08/2022
991/2662/22 HACC 01/08/2022
991/2652/22 HACC 03/08/2022
991/2652/22 HACC AC 03/08/2022
991/2652/22 HACC AC 03/08/2022
991/2726/22 HACC 04/08/2022
991/2726/22 HACC 04/08/2022
991/2873/22 HACC 09/08/2022
991/2892/22 HACC 10/08/2022 On the appointment of a preparatory court hearing
991/2873/22 HACC 10/08/2022
991/2892/22 HACC 29/08/2022
991/2892/22 HACC 30/08/2022 Decision on the consideration of a recusal
991/2873/22 HACC AC 30/08/2022
991/2892/22 HACC 31/08/2022 On the appointment of a preparatory court hearing
991/2873/22 HACC AC 31/08/2022
991/2873/22 HACC 07/09/2022
991/2873/22 HACC 07/09/2022
991/2873/22 HACC AC 07/09/2022
991/2892/22 HACC 08/09/2022
991/2892/22 HACC AC 09/02/2023 Decision on the implementation of remote court proceedings
991/2892/22 HACC AC 13/02/2023
991/2892/22 HACC AC 13/02/2023
991/2892/22 HACC AC 27/02/2023
991/2892/22 HACC 16/06/2023
991/2892/22 HACC 16/06/2023
991/2892/22 HACC 20/06/2023
991/2892/22 HACC 20/06/2023
991/2892/22 HACC 12/10/2023 Decision on closing the criminal proceedings
991/2892/22 HACC 12/10/2023 Decision on closing the criminal proceedings
991/2892/22 HACC AC 26/10/2023 On leaving the appeal without action
991/2892/22 HACC AC 06/11/2023 Opening of appeal proceedings
991/2892/22 HACC AC 21/11/2023 Completion of the preparation and appointment of the appeal hearing
991/2892/22 HACC AC 06/12/2023 Decision on the consideration of a recusal
991/2892/22 HACC AC 22/01/2024
991/2892/22 HACC AC 22/01/2024
991/2892/22 HACC AC 31/01/2024
991/2892/22 HACC AC 31/01/2024
991/2892/22 HACC AC 22/03/2024 On the appointment of a new trial in the court of the first instance
991/2892/22 HACC AC 22/03/2024 On the appointment of a new trial in the court of the first instance
991/2892/22 HACC 24/04/2024
991/2892/22 HACC 24/04/2024
991/2892/22 CCC 25/04/2024
991/2892/22 CCC 09/05/2024
991/2892/22 HACC 31/07/2024
991/2892/22 HACC 31/07/2024
991/2892/22 HACC 31/07/2024
991/2892/22 HACC 31/07/2024
991/2892/22 HACC 31/07/2024
991/2892/22 HACC 31/07/2024
991/2892/22 HACC 31/07/2024
991/2892/22 HACC 31/07/2024
991/2892/22 HACC 29/11/2024
991/2892/22 HACC AC 12/12/2024